Better Than Disneyland
By Linh Dinh
First published in Vietnam Journal, January 2002 issue
An image appeared here in the original.
In Heart of Darkness, a character named Kurtz escapes civilization and domesticity (England and his fiance) to go wild in the Congo. In Apocalypse Now, a character named Kurtz escapes civilization and domesticity (the U.S. Army and his wife) to go wild in Cambodia. Travelling upriver, each man finds his proper domain in the jungle. Surrounded by “natives,” each becomes a god, beholden to no rules of civilization. Such absolute freedom cannot go unpunished, however, and so each man is pursued by an agent from the society he has left behind. In Apocalypse Now, that agent is Willard (Martin Sheen).
As a seasoned soldier and a C.I.A. agent, with one tour of Vietnam already behind him, Willard comes off as strangely innocent and unmarked. He appears more befuddled than shell shocked, with a casual coolness Americans cultivate as a national character. His voice-over narration, as written and executed by Michael Herr, the author of “Dispatches,” is much livelier than anything that actually comes out of his mouth. At the start of the film, Willard gets drunk, strips himself, and punches a mirror. This “psychotic” episode can be interpreted as post-traumatic stress disorder, or maybe it’s just someone trashing his dorm room after a frat party. Back in the U.S. and in Saigon, Willard longs for the jungle, but it is never clear what he wants to do once he gets there. He has no real aim, not even a crazy one. He doesn’t want to save democracy or kill the Commies or even get high on the adrenaline of war. He accepts the assignment to hunt down Kurtz (Marlon Brando) with blase resignation: “I took the mission. What the hell else was I gonna do? But I didn't know what I’d do when I found him.” Willard’s passive face never betrays the angst of a Klaus Kinski in Herzog’s Aguirre: The Wrath of God, for example, to cite another crazy-quest-up-the-river movie. If anything he is a grown-up Huckleberry Finn. Instead of drifting down the Mississippi with only one Negro sidekick, however, Willard is now chugging up the Nung River in the company of Chief (Albert Hall) and Clean (Lawrence Fishburn). The rest of the strange crew on this boat is made up of California surfer dude Lance (Sam Bottoms) and saucier-wannabe Chef (Frederic Forrest). What they are heading towards is “the worst place on earth,” Kurtz’s compound in the heart of the jungle. Their gory, almost picaresque encounters along the way is the meat of this movie, its only points, because nothing really happens once they get there. The ending is a muck of half-baked ideas and well-done cinematography.
Two nutcases bookend their journey. At the mouth of the Nung River, they run into a kinetic Colonel Kilgore (Robert Duvall). He appears to symbolize the ever-optimistic, gung-ho, goofy yet deadly U.S. military machine. Attacking a village held by Charlie, he blasts Wagner’s “Ride of the Valkyries” from the sky “because it scares the hell out of the slopes.” He then cheerfully orders some of his men to surf during the firefight. When one of the soldier balks at this crazed order, Kilgore barks: “If I say it's safe to surf this beach, captain, it's safe to surf this beach!” After ordering a Napalm strike, Kilgore is enraptured: “Do you smell that? Napalm, son. Nothing else in the world smells like that. I love the smell of napalm in the morning.”
At the end of their journey, what’s left of the crew run into a raving photojournalist (Dennis Hopper). He’s not so much looney as Looney Tune. A jester in Kurtz’s court, he swoons when the master declaims poetry and gushes out trippy inanities such as “This is dialectics! It's very simple dialectics. One through nine. No maybes, no supposes, no fractions. You can't travel in space, you can't go out into space, you know, without, like, you know, with fractions.” He even managed to splice T.S. Eliot into his blathering: “I'm a little man. He's, he’s a great man! I should have been a pair of ragged claws scuttling across floors of silent seas.” And: “Look at this fuckin’ shit we're in, man! Not with a bang, with a whimper. And with a whimper, I'm fuckin’ splitting, jack!” Hard to imagine worse lines spoken by a first rate actor. Harder still to imagine war as a whimper.
You may have noticed (or maybe you haven’t) that I have so far mentioned no Vietnamese characters. That’s because there are none. The only Vietnamese speaking part belongs to a South Vietnamese Army translator, who got to yammer, “This man is dirty V.C.! He wants water! He can drink paddy water!” before Kilgore quickly shoved him off the screen. This, in a movie Coppola famously declared “is not about Vietnam. It is Vietnam.” Imagine writing an English novel without English characters. This movie, then, is really about a bunch of pale guys, Coppola included, wading into their own hearts of darkness. It is certainly not about Vietnam. I’m not even sure it’s a Vietnam War movie.
First of, the Vietnam War was essentially a civil war. The two major combatants were the North and South Vietnamese, as born out by the casualty figures: 1.1 million for the North, 223,746 for the South, as compared to 58,200 for the Americans. Of the three major offensives of the War--Tet (1968), Easter (1972), and Spring (1975), U.S. ground troops participated in only one. You will never know that, however, from watching any American Vietnam War flick, be it The Deer Hunter, Platoon, The Boys From Company C, or Apocalypse Now. In Full Metal Jacket, a U.S. grunt jokingly asks an A.R.V.N. pimp (wearing an oversized U.S. Army shirt) if he wanted to buy A.R.V.N. rifles: “They’ve never been shot, and have only been dropped once!” In the same movie, a U.S. colonel lectures: “Inside every Gook is an American trying to get out!” To many Americans, the Vietnam War was an American extravaganza, staged in Vietnam.
To concede that Vietnam was a civil war is to relegate America to a supporting role in someone’s else drama. But that is exactly what it was: someone’s else drama. In spite of all the billions spent by the U.S., the Vietnam War was essentially a Vietnamese affair. The stakes were simply much higher for them. To call it a civil war is also to acknowledge ideological differences among the Vietnamese, an impossible concept if one perceives Vietnamese as monolithic, incapable of squabbling among themselves.
It is meaningful that Kurtz got in trouble for murdering four South Vietnamese “double agents.” According to Willard: “Kurtz orders the assassination of three Vietnamese men and one woman. Two of the men were Colonels in the South Vietnamese army. Enemy activity in his old sector dropped off to nothing.” Scratch a South Vietnamese, the movie is saying, and you’ll find a North Vietnamese.
The four murdered Vietnamese at least share the distinction of being the only Vietnamese with actual names in this movie, as glimpsed on their I.D. cards. The rest are just a faceless horde scampering in the background. The most faceless people in the movie, however, are the Montagnards. They are depicted as savage yet docile. Unlike the Vietnamese double agents, they are not two-faced. To be a double agent, one has to be sly, deceitful, hypocritical, mental operations these folks are apparently not capable of performing. In fact, they seem incapable of speech: none of them has a single line in the movie. The Montagnards are so simple, so childlike, they can be scared away with sirens. Hard to square that with the fearless warriors supposedly undaunted by artilleries and napalm strikes. Fulfilling the white man’s fantasy, they worship Kurtz like a god, and after he is killed by Willard, they are ready to prostrate themselves before him too. As General Corman (G.D. Spradlin) fatuously informs Willard: “Out there with these natives it must be a temptation to be god.”
The Montagnards are also prized by Kurtz because they know how to tap into their primordial instincts: they know how to kill without feelings, just like the Viet Cong. Kurtz recounts his days in the Special Forces: “We went into a camp to inoculate the children. We left the camp after we had inoculated the children for Polio, and this old man came running after us and he was crying. He couldn't see. We went back there and they had come and hacked off every inoculated arm. There they were in a pile...A pile of little arms. And I remember I cried. I wept like some grandmother. I wanted to tear my teeth out. I didn't know what I wanted to do. And I want to remember it. I never want to forget it. I never want to forget. And then I realized... like I was shot. Like I was shot with a diamond. A diamond bullet right through my forehead. And I thought: My God, the genius of that. The genius. The will to do that. Perfect, genuine, complete, crystalline, pure. And then I realized they were stronger than we. Because they could stand that these were not monsters. These were men. Trained cadres. These men who fought with their hearts, who had families, who had children, who were filled with love, but they had the strength...the strength...to do that. If I had ten divisions of those men our troubles here would be over very quickly.” The U.S. is bound to lose the war because it doesn’t have ten divisions of noble savages. It doesn’t even have a battalion. That’s why Kurtz has to raise his own army to fight his own war. The way to win this war is to be more methodically barbaric.
The fabrication of an inspired atrocity by the Viet Cong is consistent with the movie’s preoccupation with the dark primitives. With Heart of Darkness as its ideological ballast, this is inevitable. In Conrad’s novel, the boat goes upstream towards “the earliest beginnings of the world.” Along the way they encounter Africans with “faces like grotesque masks.” One man is compared to “a dog in a parody of breeches and a feather hat walking on his hind legs.” In Apocalypse Now, Vietnam is more or less one continuous jungle, with corpses casually dangling from trees and arrows and spears flying out of the foliage. The arrow attack scene is lifted straight from Heart of Darkness, where a black river boat pilot is also impaled by a spear. The phoniness of this is breathtaking. The N.V.A. and Viet Cong did not win a modern war with arrows and spear. But a scene from a 1902 book has to be shoehorned into a 1979 movie because of Coppola’s fascination with savages.
It is also interesting that Clean and Chief, the two black members of a four-man crew, are the first two to get killed. (Chef, with his Frenchified culture, “I’m a saucier... I was supposed to go to Paris, study at the Escoffier school”, is decapitated at the very end, and only clean-cut Lance gets to go home in one piece with the other all-American, Willard.) Clean and Chief are also frozen out of a sex scene with the Playboy playmates. After Willard’s crew finds the Playboy helicopter stranded in the jungle after a U.S.O. show, the bunnies’ sexual favors are bartered by their manager (Bill Graham) for some helicopter fuel. Even as virtual white slaves, these women are beyond the reach of the brothers. In Hollywood action flicks, blacks rarely get laid-- especially with white women--and they seldom make it to the end of the movie.
As Willard’s boat travels up the Nung River, the only signs of civilization are two American Army bases and a French plantation. This has nothing to do with the Vietnam of reality. As anyone who has been to the country will tell you, Vietnam is (and was, during the war) grossly overpopulated. Rivers and roads are lined with settlements. The United States, by comparison, is more wild. In many parts of the U.S., one can drive for hours without seeing a single house, an impossible feat to accomplish in Vietnam. Another thing a visitor to Vietnam can readily see is the ubiquity of the written language-- that is, of civilization. Signs and banners are everywhere. None of this is apparent in any of the panoramic shots of Apocalypse Now. Coppola hasn’t just withhold speech from the Vietnamese, he has also banned them from writing.
The most trenchant political opinions in the movie are mouthed by a Frenchman. Near the end of their journey, Willard’s crew discover a French plantation emerging from the mist. Invited to dinner by its proprietor, Hubert de Marrais (Christian Marquand), they get to hear a mini lecture on the history of Vietnam. First de Marrais tells them that it was Americans who created the Viet Minh, a precursor to the Viet Cong, in 1945. That is nonsense. The O.S.S., later to become the C.I.A., only backed the Viet Minh in W.W. II because it was already an established guerilla group, capable of spying on the Japanese. De Marrais then tells them: “The Vietnamese were nothing. We created something out of nothing. We fight for that ... You Americans fight for the biggest nothing in history.” For the record, Vietnam was founded in 939, nearly a millennium before France could stake any claim to it. As for the United States, its objectives in Vietnam were never Colonial in nature, like France (or Belgium in the Congo), but ideological. The botched history lesson is typical of this movie. Whenever it reaches for insights or profundity, it simply unravels.
Let’s examine the moral trajectory of this movie. Coppola writes: “I feel any artist making a film about war by necessity will make an ‘anti-war’ film and all war films are usually that. My film is more of an ‘anti-lie’ film, in that the fact that a culture can lie about what’s really going on in warfare, that people are being brutalized, tortured, maimed and killed, and somehow present this as moral is what horrifies me, and perpetuates the possibility of war.” All wars brutalize, torture, maim, and kill, of course, that’s all a war is. All the main characters in the movie know and accept these facts. They even glory in them. Willard, for example, never flinches at any atrocity committed in his presence. He becomes guilty of one himself when he kills a wounded Vietnamese female civilian halfway down the river. Unlike Lance, who has machine gunned her entire family in panic, Willard shoots the Vietnamese woman cold-bloodedly, when she is no longer a threat of any kind. What caused Lance to panic was the Vietnamese woman’s hurried movement towards a basket (concealing a puppy). Her death was presaged by a scene at the beginning of the movie, when another Vietnamese civilian woman had run towards an American helicopter to blow it up with a hand grenade.
Willard kills the woman because of expediency, because he is in a hurry to get to Kurtz. He also does it for the sake of consistency. As Willard explains: “It was a way we had over here of living with ourselves. We’d cut them in half with a machine gun and give them a Band-Aid....It was a lie. And the more I saw of them, the more I hated lies.”
Kurtz is likewise not disturbed by the killings but by lies. He never questions the U.S. Army’s objectives, only its methods. Stripped of the intellectual mumbo jumbo, mysterious lighting, and about fifty pounds, and Kurtz is no different than Rambo.
The difference between Kurtz and Willard is one of degrees, not of essence. They both believe in the war, and in the extra-legal means to pursue it. Willard is himself suspected of murdering a South Vietnamese tax collector. That’s why he doesn’t quite see the logic of his mission: “Charging a man with murder in this place was like handing out speeding tickets in the Indy 500.” Willard shares Kurtz’s contempt for the U.S. military brass: “The war was being run by a bunch of four-star clowns who were going to end up giving the whole circus away.” And he admires Kurtz’s freelancing, freewheeling ways: “He could have gone for General, but he went for himself instead.” And: “The more I read and began to understand, the more I admired him.”
If Willard identifies so strongly with Kurtz, why would he want to kill him? Willard himself offers no clues: “Part of me was afraid of what I would find and what I would do when I got there. I knew the risks, or imagined I knew. But the thing I felt the most, much stronger than fear, was the desire to confront him.”
Confront him to do what? What can Kurtz possibly tell Willard that he doesn’t already know? That Time magazine is misleading? Does someone who works for the C.I.A., who traffic in lies, need to be reminded of that?
Willard’s assassination of Kurtz, then, can only be interpreted as an acquiescence to U.S. Army authority. He’s exorcising no demons. The scene itself has no drama. Emerging from a green pond, his baptism by slime, Willard sneaks into Kurtz’s room and hacks the master to death. Outside, the natives are poleaxing a water buffalo in a ritual killing. It’s a very cool scene, but the analogy is meaningless.
His mission accomplished, Willard’s only heading downstream towards the likes of Colonel Kilgore, whose similarities to Kurtz are drawn by Willard himself: “He was one of those guys that had that weird light around him. You just knew he wasn't gonna get so much as a scratch here.” Someone that invincible can only be a god, or an American film director working in the jungle, lost in his own heart of darkness.
“The horror, the horror” that is uttered by Kurtz in Heart of Darkness does not refer to the horrors of the jungle, as some believe, but the horrors of daily life anywhere. That is a much more profound point. It is also the theme in Eliot, an ultra- civilized man, a banker and an editor, who never went anywhere near a jungle. In Conrad’s book, Kurtz leaves his English fiance only to shack up with an African woman. He becomes “at home” in the jungle. Fleeing one domestic arrangement, he runs right into another. Savages, once you get to know them, turn out to be no different from the buddies and the women you’ve left behind. Rescued, or rather kidnapped, by Marlow to be brought back to England, Kurtz croaks halfway, but not before croaking out his “judgment upon the adventures of his soul on this earth”: “The horror! The horror!” Back home, his fiance is eager to hear of Kurtz’s last moments. What were his last words, she asks. Marlow answers: “The last word he pronounced was--your name.”
By briefly examining the literary source of Apocalypse Now, I’m hoping to show it in a new light. Like Kurtz in Heart of Darkness, Willard and Kurtz in Apocalypse Now are also escaping from the familiar, from the women at home, into the exotic and the unknown. After their first Vietnam tour of duty, they signed up for another. Willard confides: “When I was home after my first tour, it was worse. I’d wake up and there’d be nothing... I hardly said a word to my wife until I said yes to a divorce.” Kurtz writes in a letter to his wife: “SELL THE HOUSE. SELL THE CAR. SELL THE KIDS. FIND SOMEONE ELSE. FORGET IT. I'M NEVER COMING BACK. FORGET IT” This film, then, is not about the horrors of the jungle but its allures. Under Coppola’s direction, the jungle becomes a hotbed of wild desires, where you can hobnob with savages, shoot them, get shot in turns, burn down acres of forests, get scared by tigers, and get laid by Playboy bunnies. It becomes, in short, the ultimate theme park. The idea is to be “limitless and free,” and to get “lost in a romance...wilderness of pain,” to quote from the Doors song that begins the extravaganza. Halfway through this romp, Lance sums it all up: “Disneyland. Fuck, man, this is better than Disneyland!”
Anything to get away from “the horror, the horror” of home. As Huckleberry Finn says at the end of his own wild boat ride: “[...] she's going to adopt me and sivilize me, and I can't stand it. I been there before.”
Postscript: to those who want to experience a more authentic Apocalypse Now, may I suggest Apocalypse Now, the disco. Unlike the film, this one is actually located in Vietnam (at 2C Thi Sach Street, in downtown Ho Chi Minh City), with real Vietnamese in it. The strobe lights are just as psychedelic as the ones used in the film, and the music is just as groovy.
---
Linh Dinh is the author of a collection of stories, "Fake House" (Seven Stories Press 2000) and three chapbooks of poems, "Drunkard Boxing" (Singing Horse Press 1998), “A Small Triumph Over Lassitude” (Leroy Press 2001), and “A Glass of Water” (Skanky Possum Press 2001).
Source
The original page, Vietnam Journal January 2002, as kept by the Internet Archive: http://www.vietnamjournal.org/article.php?sid=39
More from January 2002 issue.