Vietnamese Literature in Western Languages: A Book Review
Original title: Nguyen Dinh Tham: Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature: A Preliminary Bibliography
Vietnamese literature in Western languages is the subject of this book review. David Marr of the Australian National University looks at Nguyen Dinh Tham's 1992 list of about 2,500 books and articles, most in French and English. It still helps anyone who wants to find Vietnamese poems, stories and language studies without reading Vietnamese.

Key facts
- Reviewer
- David G. Marr, Australian National University, Canberra
- Book reviewed
- Nguyen Dinh Tham, a preliminary bibliography of studies on Vietnamese language and literature (Cornell Southeast Asia Program, 1992, 228 pages)
- First published
- Asian Folklore Studies, volume 55, 1996; reprinted in Vietnam Journal, July 2002 issue
- ISBN
- 0-87727-127-5 (paperback, as given in the review)
- Type
- Book review
- What it covers
- What the bibliography lists, which languages and scholars lead it, and what it leaves out
The original article
Below is the full text as Vietnam Journal printed it, with its credit. We have not changed the authors' words.
Nguyen Dinh Tham: Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature: A Preliminary Bibliography
An image appeared here in the original.
Nguyen Dinh Tham. Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature: A Preliminary Bibliography. Southeast Asia Program Series 10. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1992. 228 pages. Paper US$18.00; ISBN 0-87727-127-5.
During the Vietnam War, tens of millions of dollars were spent by the U.S. government on surveys, interviews, field studies, and documentary translations, all designed to inform the higher government echelons about the Vietnamese enemy and the immediate sociopolitical context in which the conflict was being waged. Officials who allocated such monies did not consider the study of Vietnam's language and literature relevant to achieving victory. Inside American universities, meanwhile, several hundreds Ph. D. dissertations about Vietnam were produced in the disciplines of political science, history, and applied education, yet only a handful were written in the fields of linguistics and literature. Following the end of the war in 1975, U.S. government funds for studying anything about Vietnam dried up completely; this was mirrored in the universities, where no more than five or six acknowledged specialists managed to hang on to academic positions, and a whole generation of graduated students avoided Vietnam like the plague.
From about 1988, interest in Vietnam began to revive in the United States, although still focusing on the American experience in the war. By 1992 Vietnam had almost become the flavor-of-the-month, with economists, development studies experts, commercial lawyers, and management specialists enjoying the highest profiles. Many of these American academics were retreads from China studies, but by 1995 the background profile was more diverse, and other disciplines were represented, notably anthropology, history, archaeology, and demography. Even linguistics and literature gained a foothold.
Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature appears to be the fruit of one Vietnamese migrant laboring assiduously in Montreal since 1975, launching bibliographical sorties on major library collections, compiling a personal card file, and eventually gaining the attention of established scholars at the Cornell Southeast Asia Program. We cannot be sure, since the compiler, Nguyen Dinh Tham, provides no background to his project. It would have been nice if Mr. Tham had included a brief introduction to his bibliography telling us, for example, how and where the data was collected, specifying his criteria for including or excluding items, explaining how he delineates "literature" from "folk literature", and maybe even offering readers a few pages on how Western interest in Vietnamese language and literature began and was sustained in the more than three centuries since Fr. Alexandre de Rhodes published his Vietnamese-Portuguese-Latin dictionary in Rome (entry 138).
Whatever its genesis, Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature is a valuable bibliographical tool for any researcher who wishes to dig deeper into the Vietnamese experience than the economic forecasts, statistical surveys, and consultant reports that dominate the output today. The volume contains approximately 2,500 entries divided into four sections: Vietnamese language (29% of entries), Vietnamese literature (37%), Vietnamese folk literature (16%), and "V.N. ethnic minorities languages and literatures" (18%). No Vietnamese language publications are admitted to this bibliography, a restriction that should have been made clear in the book's title. The closest one gets to Vietnamese is the seventy bilingual dictionaries (including rare Pali-Vietnamese, Polish-Vietnamese and Vietnamese-Lao publications) and the seventy or so Western textbooks for learning Vietnamese. Perhaps Tham plans a second bibliography devoted entirely to relevant Vietnamese publications.
Among the Western languages represented in this bibliography, French occupies the pride of place with at least 45% of the total entries, spread evenly across the subject areas. This reflects the serious commitment of French scholars as well as the capacity of Vietnamese intellectuals to publish in French. It also demonstrates to young graduate students the necessity of accessing French-language materials on topics as diverse as writing systems, historical linguistics, pre-colonial poetry, twentieth-century fiction, folk narratives, and Tibeto-Burman languages.
English titles make up about 35% of the total entries, being best represented in those parts of the bibliography dealing with Vietnamese language and ethnic minorities, but less evident in the literature and folk literature sections. Russian scholars have made important contributions to research on Vietnamese lexicology, grammar, phonetics, and semantics; curiously, they are almost entirely absent from the study of ethnic minority languages and literatures. German, Hungarian, and Polish scholars made cameo appearances in this bibliography. Unfortunately, an extensive corpus of relevant publications in Japanese is ignored completely, and very few Chinese-language titles are included.
Perusing the nineteen-page index of names, one can discover who are the most prolific scholars of Vietnamese language and literature. At the top stands Nguyen Dinh Hoa, with fifty-six entries, including dictionaries, textbooks, linguistics, and folk riddles. Close behind comes Huynh Sanh Thong, with fifty-four entries, followed by David D. Thomas with twenty-five entries. Three French scholars are quite well represented: André Haudricourt (twenty-five entries), George Cordier (twenty-four entries), and Maurice Durand (twenty-one entries). Nguyen Dinh Tham has managed to uncover some rare books and journals; even those specialists who think they know everything will be in for a few surprises. However, the problem remains of how to track down individual titles. When I tried on my computer to search several library catalogs via Internet, almost none of the "treasure-house" items in the bibliography could be found. It is a pity the compiler did not include venue codes, at least for rare entries.
Annotations to individual works are very sparse, listing, for example, multiple authors contained in an edited volume or indicating where a book was reviewed. More annotation is needed especially with works of fiction, as often the title alone is not very revealing. Also, amidst the hundreds of translations of Vietnamese literature, it would have been nice if Tham had signaled for us which renditions are superior, and whether English translations had come via French (which is often the case). One has the impression that the compiler was too modest, anxious not to impose his value judgments on readers.
Although the overwhelming impression when perusing this bibliography is favorable when it comes to general coverage, inevitably a few gaps can be found. In the ethnic minorities section, there are no entries for the overseas Chinese (Hoa). The Khmer language is well represented, but nothing is listed for Khmer literature and folklore. The subsection on literature collections in translation contained twenty-nine poetry anthologies and thirty-five fiction anthologies, but not one drama compendium. The compiler seems uncertain about how to deal with nonfiction prose, in the end mostly ignoring it as a literary category. The section "Literary Works about Vietnam by Foreign Authors" opens a Pandora's box when it lists only about thirty-five titles by American poets and novelists on the Vietnam War.
Nonetheless, Studies on Vietnamese Language and Literature is a handy reference tool at a time when academics and students alike are starting to look beyond economic reports. Even economists should take note of the fact that Nguyen Dinh Tham has managed to locate sixty-five studies and translations in ten different languages of the Tale of Kieu , an early nineteenth-century epic poem by Nguyen Du that continues to entrance Vietnamese, young and old. This bibliography will be quite helpful not only to Vietnam specialists but to comparative linguists, folklorists, and cultural studies analysts as well. Teachers developing courses on Asian literature in translation will also find many valuable leads.
David G. Marr
Australian National University
Canberra
[This review first appeared in Asian Folklore Studies, volume 55, 1996, pp. 168-170. It is reprinted in The Vietnam Review, volume 2, 1997, pp. 568-570.]
The original page, Vietnam Journal July 2002, as kept by the Internet Archive: http://www.vietnamjournal.org/article.php?sid=90
What the review tells a reader today
Marr counts where the scholarship came from. About 45 percent of the entries are in French and about 35 percent are in English. A student who reads only English will miss much of the field.
He also names the scholars who appear most often. Nguyen Dinh Hoa leads with 56 entries, and Huynh Sanh Thong is close behind with 54. Their names are still a good first search in any library catalog.
His wish for library locations still matters. To find a book from the list now, search a large library catalog by its title or ISBN, or ask a librarian for an interlibrary loan. We do not sell this book and earn nothing if you look for it.
Source: the review above, by David G. Marr.
Context today
The journal that first printed this review still exists under a new name. From 1963 to 2007 it was called Asian Folklore Studies. Today it is Asian Ethnology, and it is free to read online.
The bibliography is still on the shelves of university libraries. Library records list the Southeast Asia Program at Cornell University as its publisher and 1992 as its year.
Marr ended by pointing readers to The Tale of Kiều, the long poem by Nguyễn Du. It is still the best known work in Vietnamese, with 3,254 lines in the six and eight beat form called lục bát. It has now been translated into about 20 languages.
If you want to start reading, the poem is the easiest door in. Our guide to Sino-Vietnamese words explains the old Chinese layer of the language that Marr's scholars studied.
Sources: CiNii Books library record, read 17 November 2026; Wikipedia, Asian Ethnology and The Tale of Kieu, read 17 November 2026.
Questions readers ask
Who wrote this review?
David G. Marr of the Australian National University in Canberra wrote it. It first ran in Asian Folklore Studies in 1996, and Vietnam Journal reprinted it in July 2002.
What book does the review cover?
It covers a bibliography by Nguyen Dinh Tham, printed by the Southeast Asia Program at Cornell in 1992. The book lists about 2,500 works in four parts: language, literature, folk literature and the languages of ethnic minorities.
Does the bibliography list books written in Vietnamese?
No. Marr points out that it lists only works in Western languages, with French first and English second. He says the title should have made this clear.
What gaps did Marr find?
He found nothing on the Hoa, the Chinese community of Vietnam, and nothing on Khmer stories and folklore. He also found no drama collections and very few notes on each book.
Sources
- CiNii Books, National Institute of Informatics (Japan), library record for the bibliography, read 17 November 2026
- Wikipedia contributors, Asian Ethnology, Wikipedia, read 17 November 2026
- Wikipedia contributors, The Tale of Kieu, Wikipedia, read 17 November 2026
More from July 2002 issue.