Racism and Girls - the Silent Sufferers
By Viet Duong & Xuan Duong
First published in Vietnam Journal, October 2002 issue
An image appeared here in the original.
I. Let us play a game. You tell me what names they use to call Vietnamese students: Yellow Fellow, Gook, Ching, Chong, Slaps, Slantyeyes, Slap-heads, Chinks, ecetera and ecetera.
II. Now you will often hear and probably agree with you big heart that Vietnamese students are quiet and what shy. Yes shy. Very shy. You hardly hear them say anything class, eh. Please listen to this:
My teacher often make comments in my school reports that I am "shy". Well! I’m shy I think because other students make fun of me when I speak. They make fun of my accent. They also laugh when my teacher calls out my name. They never try to call my name properly. I feel very afraid when I have to speak in class.
Basically this student had two problems: (1) Her Vietnamese name was alien to her classmates who "made no effort to learn to say it properly". (2) Her second problem was her poor English together with her heavy accent that caused her classmates to laugh at her. As a result she had been conditioned into learning that her embarrassment would be minimized if she just kept her mouth shut. Altogether.
So would you agree that the Vietnamese shyness is only a myth? A cruel myth. The student in the tape you have just heard had been branded in her school report ‘shy’. Yes shy, shy because every time she opened her mouth the class laughed. They laughed at her accent. They laughed at her poor English. They laughed because their teacher let them. This girl had always felt resentful toward her teachers because they did not do anything to defend her. To protect her. To help her through her hard time of learning: learning school lessons, learning the language, and learning how to cope and to survive her totally new environment. There we go!
III. Now let me tell you about this Year-11 girl who loved Chemistry and had been in Australia for a few years was one of two students of Vietnamese origin in her class. The other student coped with the Chemistry teacher who seemed to be unfriendly toward the two. In these girls’ eyes the teacher was not only unfriendly but also cold, unhelpful and hostile. Our girl shrunk in class so she would not be noticed by the teacher. She asked no questions. She guessed when it might be her turn to speak or present in class and she just skipped it. What she had not understood in class she merely asked someone else. For two years it was like that.
Until it was time to get ready for the HSC. Summoning all her courage she and the Vietnamese classmate went to the teacher to say their good-willed farewell. Overwhelmed by her emotions instead of saying, "Hi Miss, we‘ve come to say goodbye and thanks", she said, trembling, "Hi Miss, um where can I return the textbooks?"
Instead of an encouraging smile the teacher rolled her eyes and ground her teeth, "I have told you all where to go, haven’t I!"
For two smile-less years the girl had stayed on because she simply wanted to do the chemistry subject. And for two years she had never told anyone, apart from the classmate, of her lonely crying and the humiliation and indignity of being unfairly treated by the teacher, and her truancy as a result.
She confided to us, "As a child I’d been told stories about fearsome spirits and ghosts. I was fearful of spirits and ghosts though I’d never seen one. But I guess my fear of my Chemistry teacher was now even worse."
What do you think?
IV. Now about this girl who was in a group of girls often harassed by other girls of another ethnic background. Say if this group was having lunch in a tree shade the other group would come and say, "This is our spot, you girls go somewhere else to sit, OK." This group might reply in return, "You can’t own a shade. We’re here first, so this is our spot". The other group might then show that they were of bigger-build, more numerous, and more aggressive, "No, you must go. Go, go." The other group had no choice but to stand up and go somewhere else.
This girl studies hard as expected by family and others. Often she was called, "smart arse", "nerdy" etc… and treated with hostility by girls of the other ethnic background.
Racial tension all the time glimmered in the school grounds. At times young people of the two ethnic background fought with physical violence at the local train station.
Feeling desperate and unsafe, the girl had never thought, never, of talking about all this with a teacher or other school staff.
V. What about this other case, a junior girl attending a girls’ school had been constantly picked on by other girls. The other girls were quite imaginative in that they were always been able to find something to pick on this poor little girl. For either the way she handled the cutlery, or the way she sat or squatted, or the way she chewed her lunch, or the accent in which she spoke her English. There was always something there for other girls to laugh at, to mock, to tease, to taunt …
Almost every day the girl cried and nagged her parents about changing schools. Almost always her parents would offer the Vietnamese equivalent of ‘she’ll be right honey’.
But both the parents and their ‘honey’ had never approached the school for help or anything like that.
VI. So! Are you tired of hearing about this ‘silent sufferers’ business. I hope you are not, these girls’ pain should not act like sleeping tablets. They are stimulants that urge caring people like you to do something about it. Anyway I will now read you a poem for a change. It is actually part of a poem in this book of poems, called Hey, I’ve got a racist flu!
EVEN MY TEARS TRY THEIR BEST!
Sure I see you all there
surrounding each other’s laughter
with the collusion of the green lawn
I will wait
out here
for the bell
to send you lot
to our class
first
You jump
you scream
you swear
noisily
at the wet bottoms of your pants
No, not really!
Not the dew that hangs on the grass
that is from my tears
You all must be blind
not seeing my tears
all over our school
You are so good
at mimicking my accent
to scold that I “don’t belong here!”
You are so skilful
at showing my pains
on your own faces
Only your faces do not sustain the cuts
of searching for the suitable vocabularies
then the right grammar to connect them
into froth. Then the gale to force them out.
But you can’t make me laugh
my breath only returns
when our school gate
no longer sits in my mind
But my smiles
only dare to show up
only when the walls of my home
have already hauled me in
You are all really excelling
in developing school phobia
and planting it in my cells
As soon as seeing the gate
hazy in the distance
my eyes call up my tears
"Please get set!"
So, this student had developed serious school phobia because she was teased and taunted by non-Vietnamese-non-Asian students at school. In our projects this student was truly the one who had cried more than any other. In fact none other had endured any pain near her level of suffering.
And what had kept her at school all those years, thank goodness, was what no one knew.
VII. Then this girl who moved herself from a co-ed high school to a girls school in the hope that she would be more at home with other girls of her similar background than the largely-built boys that looked too intimidating. Yes, lucky her. She was blossoming among her girl friends. But unfortunately they were not a favourite group in the eye of an important office staff in the school. As a result our girl had over the years tried her best not to go near that office window. Until she left school. No one among the school staff ever knew that girl had always avoided that particular office window. And why! Only silence had witnessed that!
VIII. Well then let us hear about this junior girl! every time she passed this particular group of students of another ethnic background they spoke loud in mocked Vietnamese. Like ‘du ma’. And laughed. They pulled their own eyes into a slanting shape. And laughed. They even poked out their legs so suddenly that she tripped and fell. While she said ‘sorry’ to them, they just laughed. As if a most funny street show.
Would she think of seeking help? You may wonder.
No! She hoped ‘it will go away’ with time. True! It went away. When she recognised and identified all of the racist students and simply avoided them. Not to be seen at all.
Isn’t she clever? What do you think?
IX. But you haven’t heard of a dramatic move yet. Here it comes!
This young girl had always felt at home at her school in Cabramatta although her English was often peppered with Vietnamese as she and her mother had joined her father for only a short while. Then drama! Her father’s work shifted the whole family interstate. Her new school duly welcomed her. But the colourful eyes in her class did not recognise her. Only loneliness, shyness, exclusion, and indifference were willing to accept her.
She had agonized so much for a whole year that eventually the family decided to move back to where she once felt she belonged.
You may ask, "What about her father’s job?" But then you yourself may ask, "What about the girl’s well-being?"
I could just stand here and tell you story after story of girls who felt too ashamed of themselves or too fearful to tell the school of their ordeal. But what about your time?
X. Hang on a minute! What about this girl?
At times she heard other students in mocked Vietnamese while she was present. Indirectly in class other students talked about "Australia being swamped by Asians", and things like "Do I then have to do things the Asian way?"
She felt even more lonely, uncertain, and distressed when going with her parents in their car to places. While waiting at the traffic lights they were often shouted at in mocked Asian languages as if they did not belong here.
Her wish was simply to move home to a place with more Vietnamese or Asian presence. Then she would go to a school with more faces like her.
Let’s listen to her voice.
No! we, my parents and I, don’t talk about it. The business of racism. We only talk about study and stuff. No, I don’t talk about it with my friends. Racism, we pretend it does not happen. Racism, not something that we want to talk about.
XI. So what do you think about this feeling like being singled out for taunting and discrimination. Can you see that the vast majority of girls in our projects keep their pains to themselves, suffering alone, no relaying to no sharing with their school what so ever. They want to move: move themselves out of that class; out of that school; out of that suburb; even out of that state.
For further understanding of the issue you might like to refer to our projects
- Surviving Racism, published in Integration, the Magazine for Multicultural & Vietnamese Issues, No 16.
- Hey, I’ve got a racist flu! A poetry book that highlights the stories told by Vietnamese students.
In the mean time let’s talk about what can be done to address these issues:
So do you really think Vietnamese students are shy at school or in class? NO NO of course NOT. They are only being conditioned into shyness. Self-defeat. Surrender! What can be done to help them then? There are many things. But the immediate measures should be:
- To empower Vietnamese students, especially those in Year 7-8-9, so that they will come forward, speak up and seek help, within their school.
But why empower you may ask, as all mechanisms of anti-racism seem to be in place at school. There is this anti-racism officer, this school counselor, this year teacher, sometimes this Vietnamese-speaking community liaison officer, this deputy principal, and there our principal. All of them are willing to help and support, in accordance with their departmental polices. And there are manuals, fliers, newsletters, websites. Beautiful!
The problem is the students either
- don’t know about them;
- don’t trust them;
- ares ashamed to talk about it;
- are scared of the authority to speak out; or
- are fearful of further revenge from the bully(ies)
So Please please please don’t let this go on and on forever.
- To research into the effect of racism on Vietnamese students, especially girls. For better understanding of their suffering and for better helping measures.
Why research? You may again ask. Well, it has been well documented that adolescent victims of racism may develop low self-esteem, problems with development, depression and other mental health concerns including a suicidal tendency, school phobia, truancy, early school leaving, alcohol and drug abuse, joining a gang, and so on.
However there has not been any comprehensive research into the issue to measure the extent of suffering and damage that this group of adolescents have endured over the years.
Clearly this is a serious issue that will definitely have severe future consequences. This is half of my speech. The other half will be presented in the afternoon workshop.
IN CONCLUSION for this session may I share with you all an article by Futurist Phillip Ruthven (Australia of the Future, The Bulletin, last week 23.4.02, p.54) who predicts that Australia’s “better health, improved diets and fewer accidents will continue to raise life expectancy across the board”. We’ll enjoy “lower (paid) working hours per year, more holidays, long service leave and a greater array of leisure activities on offer”. And that “there will be increased rights and opportunities for women in the workforce, politics, religions and other institutions”. But also “further steps will be taken to outlaw discrimination on the basis of gender”, age, religion, disabilities, and of course to outlaw all forms of discrimination on the basis of RACE and ETHNICITY.
Let’s then hope that Australia of the future will be a truly great place to live. For all including Vietnamese-Australians women and girls.
POSTSCRIPT:
A study by a team of leading academics in Melbourne had found that up to 69 percent ( or 7 out of 10) of Vietnamese High School students in Victoria had experienced racism at school, and that many of them had even come to “the brink of mental collapse”. As reported in the Sydney Morning Herald, 1993.
Well then you may say ‘oh, 1993, that’s old stuff!’
Well, last Monday (22.4.2002) a broadcast on SBS Radio indicates youth in Moscow, Russia attack and murder non-white people, including those in groups that have been in Russia for several generations. And those whose foreparents have helped Russia defend against foreign invasions. Then Viet Luan newspaper, three days ago (Tuesday 23.4.2002) reported that three Vietnamese-Russians and two Chinese-Russians have been murdered by extremists in Moscow.
So there racism is never old. Racism is born and re-born all the time!
Further Recommendations
1. The Community Youth Support Taskforce in 1993 recommended that, since factors which prevent young people from successfully achieving employment and personal independence include discrimination on grounds of racial and ethnic origins:
There needs to be “involvement of community groups and young people in the preparation of the Department of School Education’s Anti-Racism Policy”.
2. The Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission in 1999 found empirical evidence that racism exists in Australia, including harassment in the streets, in supermarkets and in workplaces. Those who had experienced public expressions of prejudice and racial hatred reported that “this had a serious impact on their participation in Australian society”. HREOC also “confirmed that those individuals who were most visibly different were at greater risk of encountering racism”. Those who experienced racism might deny the experience to themselves and to others, and may not be prepared to discuss it. This can lead to even greater social isolation and lower self-esteem. HREOC therefore recommended that:
There needs to be future research into the nature of people’s experience of racism and into effective strategies for the prevention of racism;
And we need State and Federal anti-discrimination bodies to continue to ensure that their recruitment and employment programs encourage a cultural diversity which reflects the communities they serve. Ensuring cultural diversity in the education system is especially relevant here.
3. Rogelia Pe-Pua in 1996 undertook research with young people in the Cabramatta area, finding that “Racism is a serious issue, among students of NESB in both High School and TAFE”. She found the existence of both overt racism, citing “racial conflicts and fights among students of ethnic backgrounds, and teachers treating students differently because of their race”, and covert racism, offering the example of “teachers [giving] some ethnic students more work to do without corresponding support under the guise of helping students from disadvantaged backgrounds; or when school staff have lower expectations of students because they happen to belong to an ethnic group”. In addition, school staff may “cover up” racial incidents.
Indeed, some students feel that nothing can be done about racism because of “a common perception among many NESB students that schools ignore, do not take seriously or simply gloss over complaints of racist treatment by teachers or fellow students”.
Moreover, both Pe-Pua and our project “Surviving Racism” found that many students are unaware of the existence of Anti-Racism Contact Officers or doubt the effectiveness of these officers.
Based on these findings, Pe-Pua recommends that:
“What is important is for schools to take a stand that racism and discrimination will not be tolerated, and to make known through various actions that they are serious about enforcing this principle. Sometimes, even if the racist encounter is not resolved, the fact that it has been brought to the attention of the school and given proper treatment can deter incidents from occurring”.
And “That school administrations make known to students and community groups the existence and role of Anti-Racism Contact Officers as well as their rights to access; and that complaints of racist treatment at all levels within the [Department of Education and Training] be reported and fully investigated”.
They can be an important means of general education and prevention as well as assistance for victims of racial abuse and bullying.
4. Our research in the project called “Surviving Racism” revealed that students of Vietnamese background are “a lot more quiet and timid”. They feel that “I’d rather stay away from trouble”, “If there is a conflict then I will stay away from it, and keep quiet about it because I don’t want it to become even more of a problem,” and that “Oh! It will go away”. Therefore,
Teachers must be made aware that Vietnamese-Australian students may be more vulnerable to racial attacks than students of other ethnic backgrounds by virtue of their relative passivity.
Schools should also assist students of Vietnamese origin to stand up for themselves in a constructive manner.
5. Students of Vietnamese descent who experience racism from their peers and others often feel ashamed of their culture, race and their own identity, indeed at a crucial time of their lives in which they are trying to establish who they are. Further, Mary Robinson from the UNHCR recently spoke of men and women’s different experiences of racial discrimination, noting that women and girls suffer it more often. This is because they are easily visible and are seen as easy targets. Thus, as Amrita Dasvarma has observed “women are often punished for what men do” eg. after September 11 women wearing hijabs were harassed in the streets. Moreover, it must be noted that Vietnamese girls often suffer double or even triple discrimination, especially in schools where there is a tendency to reward female passivity and indoctrinate girls and boys in stereotypical sex roles. How does a girl then gain a sense of her self in such a system which devalues the female mind and experience and in addition to that denies the value of her cultural identity?
Most importantly, attitudes and beliefs must be changed. It is imperative that students be made aware of the harm caused by their racist attacks aimed at others and that these attacks are a legal offence. Racial conflict has been recorded mostly between students of Arabic, South Pacific Islander and Asian backgrounds due mainly to the lack of mutual understanding of cultural aspects and differences in physical appearance.
Creative strategies should be implemented to instill in young people the benefits of inclusion, for example:-
- Regular school activities such as Multicultural Day, Vietnamese Day, South Pacific Islander Day, Multicultural Food Day, offering students the opportunity to see, learn and appreciate other cultures and share.
- Peer Support Programs and anti-racism and anti-bullying workshops should be conducted to raise students’ understanding of racism and bullying, and effective ways to deal with it. Students can be sensitized to these issues role-plays and role-reversals where the bully takes on the role of the victim while the victim or another student the role of the bully.
- Schools should enlist the help of interpreters and Vietnamese organizations to run workshops for parents of Vietnamese background, to increase their understanding of the school environment. Discussion should be held with these parents on how they can assist their children to resolve negative experiences at school.
In addition to these, is the importance of incorporating issues of multiculturalism and racism into the school syllabus. John Schilb, teaching at Denison College required students to complete an assignment where ‘they had to consider what it meant to be black or white or male or female at their high school, choosing a category to which they did not belong. They would thereby be reviewing their personal backgrounds, yet in an unfamiliar light, one that encompassed people whose orientation they had not shared. Learning to perceive past events from new perspectives, those of people whom they had, perhaps unwittingly, excluded, compels students to become aware of the exclusion and its effects”.
Indeed, the current value systems in our society are such that in my law course at university, the subject “Discrimination & the Law” is only an elective, while commerce-related courses like “Business Organisations” and “Property Law” are compulsory. Why is that? Why is it a topic that is left up to a teacher or school’s discretion, with the emphasis on the victim after an incident has occurred. Fundamentally there needs to be an ongoing challenge to the dominant thinking and value systems in our society in order for such problems as racism to be tackled at their very roots.
This is an edited speech delivered by Viet Duong at the Conference Vietnamese Family: Myth vs Reality, by the Federation of Vietnamese Women’s Associations in Australia, on 26.4.02 in Sydney
Viet Duong is in her final year (6th) of a law degree. Since a highschooler Viet has been involved in the production of Integration, the Magazine for Multicultural & Vietnamese Issues. As well as involved in helping Vietnamese asylum seekers in Hong Kong and Southeast Asia through working with the NSW Vietnamese Refugee Support Committee. Currently Viet is a member of the federal government sponsored 2202 Youth Round Table Project on environmental issues. Viet has also been involved in the three innovative projects:
- Surviving Racism sponsored by the VCA/NSW and NSW Community Relations Commission;
- Growing in Harmony in 1999 & 2000, sponsored by NSW Department of Education and Training and other community agencies; and
- Hey’ I’ve got a racist flu! A literary project sponsored by the Australia Council for the Arts.
Source
The original page, Vietnam Journal October 2002, as kept by the Internet Archive: http://www.vietnamjournal.org/article.php?sid=110
More from October 2002 issue.